Menu of Farmer's Daughter in Westfield, New York, USA

Menu Overview

Farmer's Daughter, located in Westfield, NY, stands out as a charming ice cream shop that doubles as a burger haven. Its menu is a nostalgic nod to classic Americana, with handcrafted items that invite you to slow down and savor each bite and spoonful.

The highlight of their ice cream offerings is undoubtedly the Large Sundae and the Mexican Sundae—both rich, indulgent treats that reflect a traditional approach to dessert, free from shortcuts. The Twist Ice Cream Cone offers a playful balance of flavors, perfect for those seeking a refreshing yet creamy finish. Loyal customers, like Evelyn D., reminisce about the memorable taste of their Fireball ice cream, which continues to captivate palates with its unique, lingering flavor.

Beyond desserts, Farmer's Daughter has made a name for itself with its expertly crafted burgers. The smash burger style is a defining feature—juicy patties with cheese melted integrally rather than simply layered on top, delivering a more harmonious mouthfeel. Paul Hornbuckle’s experience with the Sunrise and Haystack burgers underscores the quality and attention to detail: from crispy bacon and fried eggs to handcrafted onion tangles and fresh cheddar. These aren't just burgers; they’re perfected comfort food, showcasing craft and freshness down to the house-made pickles, as noted by Tabitha M.

While the spot lacks traditional indoor dining and the amenities may be modest, the flavors more than compensate for a casual setting. Prices lean on the higher side, especially for families, but the quality and authenticity justify the expense for many visitors. The outdoor tables might show signs of wear, but the dedication to hand-making each burger and each scoop of ice cream shines through irresistibly.

In essence, Farmer’s Daughter blends the warmth of a local favorite with the rigor of carefully prepared food. It’s a testament to the value of doing things “the good old fashioned way.” Whether you're craving a memorable burger or classic ice cream treats, this spot delivers a sincere and gratifying experience that echoes long after the last bite or lick.